What Happened to Edibles Restaurant & Pub? (Horsham, PA)

Restaurant: Impossible (Food Network) visited Edibles Restaurant & Pub, a family-owned tavern-style restaurant owned by John and Butzy Hurley at 561 Horsham Road in Horsham, Pennsylvania, for the episode "Barely Edible," which aired July 21, 2013. As shown in the episode, the business was struggling with falling sales and outdated food and service, prompting host Robert Irvine's team to spend about $10,000 and roughly two days reworking the restaurant's menu, kitchen operations and dining room in the show's standard format, addressing the food quality, service and business-management issues the show typically targets. As part of the renovation and relaunch, the Hurleys rebranded the business, dropping the Edibles name in favor of Hurley's American Grille, a change the owners kept after the show aired while continuing to run the restaurant themselves at the same Horsham Road address.

The name change did not translate into a lasting turnaround. A fan site report placed the restaurant's closure in late December 2014, roughly a year and a half after the episode aired, though that specific date has not been independently confirmed by a named local news outlet. What can be confirmed through business listings is the restaurant's longer-term status: a Yelp listing for the original Edibles name, updated as recently as June 2026, marks the address permanently closed, and a separate Yelp listing for the successor Hurley's American Grille, updated in August 2025, likewise shows it permanently closed.

A Yellow Pages listing for Hurley's American Grille similarly identifies the business as closed. No subsequent reopening under a different name or new ownership at 561 Horsham Road has been identified, and business-directory listings for the address do not show an operating restaurant there, though that alone does not establish the property's current physical condition or use.