Agnello's Pizzeria Is Now Mille Luci Pizzeria — Restaurant Stakeout Update

The fourth episode of Restaurant Stakeout, "The Son and the Father," aired March 28, 2012, and covered Agnello's Brick Oven Pizzeria in New City, New York, the third of three neighboring Rockland County restaurants the show featured in close succession. The series' format uses hidden cameras to record staff behavior when no one is meant to be watching, and Willie Degel reviews that footage with the owner to identify and fix service or management gaps, in this case framed around a father-and-son ownership dynamic. Agnello's owner was not directly quoted alongside the Lexington Grille and Mt. Ivy Café owners in contemporaneous coverage of the three Rockland County episodes, but Wikipedia's article on Restaurant Stakeout describes the series generally as staged, citing a 2012 realityblurred.com report on producer-directed incidents and coached cast members at these Rockland County locations.

The pizzeria's longtime address, 170 N. Main Street, now operates under a different name: Mille Luci Pizzeria, an Italian restaurant and pizzeria that appears on Yelp with an update dated March 2026 and on OpenTable with an active 2026 listing, both showing current hours and an active DoorDash ordering integration at the same storefront. Whether the change represents a straightforward rebrand, a sale, or a new lease was not confirmed, but two independent, dated sources agree the address is active under the new name.