TV Restaurants

What Happened to Cream & Sugar Cafe After Food Paradise? (Bethel, CT)

Closed verified

As of September 2026, Cream & Sugar Cafe has closed — confirmed via Yelp, August 2026.

Primary source
Yelp ·
Secondary source
Foursquare

Last verified

What the source shows: Yelp's listing for Cream & Sugar Cafe is marked permanently closed as of an August 2026 update, and Foursquare's listing for the business is separately tagged 'Now Closed.'

Interactive map — loads when you ask for it.

Everything on this map is also in the list below.

© OpenStreetMap contributors © CARTO

What happened after Food Paradise?

'Extreme Eats' featured Cream & Sugar Cafe, a Bethel, Connecticut dessert cafe owned by Alyce Kallman that became known for its oversized milkshake creations, or 'freakshakes.' The cafe operated from Pt. Barnum Square in downtown Bethel. According to Yelp, a listing updated 2026-08 marks Cream & Sugar Cafe permanently closed. Foursquare's listing for the business is also tagged 'Now Closed.' The address is unrelated to Dr. Mike's Ice Cream, a separate, longer-running Bethel ice cream shop on Greenwood Avenue that a Google Places search mistakenly returned in its place.

Featured on Food Paradise

Season / episode
Season 19, Episode 23
Original air date
Not confirmed
Episode title
Extreme Eats
What was featured
Oversized 'freakshakes' and desserts at a Bethel dessert cafe
Role
Featured restaurant
Name on the broadcast
Cream & Sugar Cafe

Frequently asked questions

Is Cream & Sugar Cafe still open in 2026?

As of September 2026, Cream & Sugar Cafe has closed — confirmed via Yelp, August 2026.

What happened to Cream & Sugar Cafe after Food Paradise?

'Extreme Eats' featured Cream & Sugar Cafe, a Bethel, Connecticut dessert cafe owned by Alyce Kallman that became known for its oversized milkshake creations, or 'freakshakes.' The cafe operated from Pt. As of September 2026, Cream & Sugar Cafe has closed — confirmed via Yelp, August 2026.

Is Cream & Sugar Cafe permanently closed?

As of September 2026, Cream & Sugar Cafe has closed — confirmed via Yelp, August 2026. We publish a closure only with a dated source behind it, and we say plainly when it has not been independently confirmed.

Where is Cream & Sugar Cafe located?

7 Pt Barnum Sq, Bethel, CT 06801. That is the address on the record as of September 7, 2026.

What season and episode of Food Paradise featured Cream & Sugar Cafe?

Season 19, Episode 23 of Food Paradise. The episode is titled “Extreme Eats”.

Every status on this site carries a confidence label and a date, and names the source it rests on. Read the Editorial & Corrections Policy for what each label means and how quickly we act on corrections. The questions above are generated from this record's own published fields — we never publish a question we cannot answer from the data.

More from Food Paradise

Every Food Paradise restaurant we track

Other TV restaurants in Connecticut

All Connecticut locations

Nearest tracked restaurants

Visit info

Address
7 Pt Barnum Sq, Bethel, CT 06801
Venue type
cafe
Official website
drmikesic.com

Businesses change fast. Always confirm directly with the restaurant — call ahead, or check its own current website or social media — before making plans around anything on this page.

Sources

  • Yelp — https://www.yelp.com/biz/cream-and-sugar-cafe-bethel
  • Foursquare — https://foursquare.com/v/cream--sugar-cafe/571ab5b2498eb2d9a3c4d7c5

See something wrong?

We work hard to keep every status accurate and dated, but restaurants change fast and our sources aren't perfect. If something here is wrong — a status, a name, an address, anything — tell us what you're seeing and where you saw it, and we'll check it.

See something wrong? Tell us →

Share this page

Record fp-1630 · last verified .