Is Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish Still Open? Best Thing I Ever Ate Update

Best Thing I Ever Ate, Season 5, Episode 3

The 'Smoky' episode (S5E3) featured Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish, a smoked fish restaurant on Pasadena Avenue South in South Pasadena, Florida, a fitting subject for an episode built around smoked food. According to Wikipedia, revised 2026-07-11, the business is described as a historic smoked fish and hamburger restaurant in South Pasadena. That description places both the restaurant's smoked-fish specialty and its hamburger menu together as the two anchors of the business's identity, consistent with the reputation the restaurant is known for locally. This television appearance adds to the restaurant's history of press and broadcast attention as a longstanding, regionally known name in smoked-fish cooking.

Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, Season 27, Episode 4 Aired July 28, 2017

On Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives (Food Network), this appearance in the "Fun in the Sun" episode, which aired 2017-07-28, revisited Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish in South Pasadena, Florida. According to Wikipedia, founder Ted Peters opened the smoked fish and hamburger stand on Madeira Beach in 1947 and moved it to South Pasadena in 1949, and the restaurant still serves its meals on stools and picnic tables in a casual, open-air setting near the water. The menu includes wood-smoked mullet, hamburgers, German potato salad, and Manhattan clam chowder, per the same source, which also notes the restaurant's appearance on Food Network's The Best Thing I Ever Ate. Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives first featured the restaurant in January 2009, according to Flavortownusa's episode guide.

Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives, Season 2, Episode 5 Aired October 29, 2007

Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives featured Ted Peters Famous Smoked Fish in the "Viewer's Choice" episode, which aired 2007-10-29, highlighting the restaurant's wood-smoked mullet. Ted Peters is a casual seafood restaurant in South Pasadena, Florida, seated at stools and picnic tables, that traces its founding to the late 1940s under founder Ted Peters, who relocated the business from Madeira Beach to its current South Pasadena address in 1949, according to the restaurant's Wikipedia entry. A Yelp business listing for the restaurant, updated 2026-07, showed continuing customer reviews and no permanent-closure marking, and that Wikipedia entry carries no closure notice either. The restaurant's own directions page, tedpetersfish.com, lists 1350 Pasadena Avenue South as its address. No news coverage of a closure, sale, or relocation was found in this check.