Is Creekside Inn Still Open? Hotel Impossible Update (Tavernier, FL)

Creekside Inn is a waterfront lodging property at 90611 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida, in the Islamorada area of the upper Florida Keys. It was featured on Hotel Impossible in the episode 'Owner Overboard' (S4E2), which aired 2014-02-03; the specific ownership or operational issues Anthony Melchiorri addressed during the visit are not documented in the sources reviewed for this record. Google Places lists Creekside Inn as operational at the Old Highway address, with a website at mycreeksideinn.com. The website was checked on 2026-09-09 and carried an HTTP last-modified header of Tuesday, September 8, 2026 -- one day before the check -- along with a 2026 copyright notice and a live room-booking system offering multiple room types, including king, queen, and accessible water-view rooms.

The site's booking calendar returned selectable dates as far out as 2029, consistent with an active, forward-looking reservation system. The homepage also lists current offers, activities, and a photo gallery, and describes the property as a waterfront inn in the Florida Keys. No source reviewed indicated a change in the inn's name, ownership, or address since the 2014 episode aired. The property is listed under the same Creekside Inn name in both Google Places and its current website, at an address in Tavernier rather than the Islamorada location named when the episode aired, though Tavernier is within the greater Islamorada area of the Keys.