Best Thing I Ever Ate All-Star: Every Restaurant and Where It Is Now
All-Star: 36 of 51 still open 8 episodes
36 of the 51 All-Star restaurants we have researched are still open; 15 have closed. All-Star of Best Thing I Ever Ate ran 8 episodes . 1 of the open restaurant has been renamed, relocated or sold to new owners. Each one carries its own dated source.
Every episode in All-Star
| Ep. | Restaurant | City | Aired | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bo Brooks Restaurant Sensational Sandwiches | Baltimore, MD | — | Closed |
| 1 | Fiore's Deli (Fiore's House of Quality) Sensational Sandwiches | Hoboken, NJ | — | Open |
| 1 | Little Goat Diner Sensational Sandwiches | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 1 | Mason Dixie Biscuit Co. Sensational Sandwiches | Washington, DC | — | Closed |
| 1 | Mile End Deli (Mile End Delicatessen) Sensational Sandwiches | Brooklyn, NY | — | Open |
| 1 | White House Subs Sensational Sandwiches | Atlantic City, NJ | — | Open |
| 2 | Fukuburger Pizza and Burgers | Las Vegas, NV | — | Open |
| 2 | Guy Fieri's Vegas Kitchen & Bar Pizza and Burgers | Las Vegas, NV | — | Open |
| 2 | Joe Squared Pizza and Burgers | Baltimore, MD | — | Closed |
| 2 | Lou Malnati's Pizza and Burgers | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 3 | Babystacks Cafe Deep-Fried Decadence | Las Vegas, NV | — | Open |
| 3 | Cafe China Deep-Fried Decadence | New York, NY | — | Open |
| 3 | Charles' Country Pan Fried Chicken Deep-Fried Decadence | New York, NY | — | Closed |
| 3 | Chef Vola's Deep-Fried Decadence | Atlantic City, NJ | — | Open |
| 3 | Proxi Deep-Fried Decadence | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 3 | Townline BBQ Deep-Fried Decadence | Sagaponack, NY | — | Open |
| 4 | Cafe Martorano (Martorano's) Marvelous Meats | Fort Lauderdale, FL | — | Open |
| 4 | Charcoal Style Marvelous Meats | White Marsh, MD | — | Open |
| 4 | Cooks & Captains Marvelous Meats | Brooklyn, NY | — | Closed |
| 4 | Purple Pig Marvelous Meats | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 4 | Roberto's Taco Shop Marvelous Meats | Las Vegas, NV | — | Open |
| 4 | Sepia Marvelous Meats | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 5 | Chef Point Café Magical Combos | Watauga, TX | — | Closed |
| 5 | Fahrenheit Magical Combos | Cleveland, OH | — | Open |
| 5 | Funk 'n Waffles Magical Combos | Syracuse, NY | — | Open |
| 5 | L'Atelier de Joël Robuchon, MGM Grand Magical Combos | Las Vegas, NV | — | Open |
| 5 | Oh My Burger Magical Combos | Gardena, CA | — | Open |
| 5 | Rito's Bakery & Deli Magical Combos | Brunswick, OH | — | Open |
| 5 | Robicelli's Magical Combos | Brooklyn, NY | — | Closed |
| 6 | Barrel & Ashes Brilliant Barbecue | Los Angeles, CA | — | Closed |
| 6 | Del Campo Brilliant Barbecue | Washington, DC | — | Closed |
| 6 | Dinosaur Bar-B-Que Brilliant Barbecue | New York, NY | — | Open |
| 6 | Fox Bros. Bar-B-Q Brilliant Barbecue | Atlanta, GA | — | Open |
| 6 | Park's BBQ Brilliant Barbecue | Los Angeles, CA | — | Open |
| 6 | Smoke Daddy Brilliant Barbecue | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 6 | The Corner Stable Brilliant Barbecue | Cockeysville, MD | — | Open |
| 6 | Tom, Dick & Hank Brilliant Barbecue | College Park, GA | — | Relocated |
| 7 | Bardot Brasserie Unbeatable Breakfast | Paradise, NV | — | Open |
| 7 | Blue Moon Café Unbeatable Breakfast | Baltimore, MD | — | Open |
| 7 | Bongo Room Unbeatable Breakfast | Chicago, IL | — | Open |
| 7 | Grove Hill Unbeatable Breakfast | Chagrin Falls, OH | — | Closed |
| 7 | Peter Pan Donut & Pastry (Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop) Unbeatable Breakfast | Brooklyn, NY | — | Open |
| 7 | Primanti Brothers Unbeatable Breakfast | Pittsburgh, PA | — | Open |
| 7 | République Unbeatable Breakfast | Los Angeles, CA | — | Open |
| 8 | Big Gay Ice Cream Truck Supreme Sweets | New York, NY | — | Closed |
| 8 | Brooklyn Diner Supreme Sweets | New York, NY | — | Open |
| 8 | Gato Supreme Sweets | New York, NY | — | Closed |
| 8 | Le Cirque Supreme Sweets | New York, NY | — | Closed |
| 8 | Serendipity 3 Supreme Sweets | Las Vegas, NV | — | Closed |
| 8 | Simona's Bakery Supreme Sweets | Sea Girt, NJ | — | Open |
| 8 | Supper Supreme Sweets | Philadelphia, PA | — | Closed |