| 1 | Holiday | — | Beachcomber BBQ & Grill , Boka Restaurant , Casa Adela , Emporio Rulli , Peking Gourmet Inn , Concord's Colonial Inn , The Patterson House , The Rotunda at Neiman-Marcus | Open Open Open Open Open Open Open Open |
| 2 | Hometown Favorites | — | Alcenia's , Chefs of New York , Duke's Bar B-Que , Jack's Cosmic Dog , Marshland , St. John's Club , Umami Burger , Vine Street Cafe | Open Open Open Open Open New owners Closed Open |
| 3 | Cheesy | — | Angelini Osteria & Alimentari , Artisanal Bistro , Bon Ton Prime Rib , Cafe des Artistes , E.A.T. , La Goulue , Zinc Bistro | Open Closed Renamed Closed Open Closed Open |
| 4 | Salty Goodness | — | Baked , Bottega , Czuchraj Meats , Kanella Grill , Les Madeleines , Pietro's , The Dillard House , Tsar Nicoulai, Ferry Building | Open Open Open Open Closed Relocated Open Open |
| 5 | Meat-Fest | — | Amada , Cold Spring Tavern , Incanto , Joe Boston's Italian Beef , No. 7 , Resto , Salumeria Rosi Parmacotto , Sardinia Enoteca Restaurante | Open Open Closed Closed Open Closed Open Closed |
| 6 | Snack Attack | — | A.O.C. , Craftsteak , Downtown Bakery , Kogi BBQ , McClure's Pickles , Paia Fish Market , Socca , Union Square Cafe | Open Closed Open Open Relocated Open Closed Open |
| 7 | Chocolate | — | Buckeye Roadhouse , Etats-Unis , Hominy Grill , Jean Georges , Kee's Chocolates , Levain Bakery , Loteria Grill , May Street Bakery | Open Closed Closed Open Open Open Open Unknown |
| 8 | Crunchy | — | Akasha , Beach Bakery Cafe , Blue Ribbon at Brooklyn Bowl , Chinatown Brasserie , E&O Kitchen and Bar , Flo's Clam Shack , Le Bernardin | Closed Open Open Closed Renamed Open Open |
| 9 | The Classics | — | Butter Lane , Carney's Restaurant , House of Prime Rib , Il Vagabondo , K-Paul's Louisiana Kitchen , Parc , 1770 House Restaurant & Inn , WoodSpoon | Closed Open Open Closed Closed Open Open Closed |
| 10 | Guilty Pleasures | — | Bouchon Bakery , Cabbyshack , Dangerously Delicious Pies , Mother's Restaurant , Pete and Sam's Restaurant , Restaurant Iris , Strip House Steak House , The Greenhouse Tavern | Closed Open Open Open Open Relocated Open Closed |
| 11 | Hot and Spicy | — | Devi , Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams , Jitlada , Loaves & Fishes , Penang Garden , Raz'z Bar and Grill , St. Elmo Steak House , Urbanbelly | Closed Open Open Open Open Closed Open Relocated |
| 12 | Totally Unexpected | — | A Salt & Battery , D'Angelo Bakery , Evvia Estiatorio , Humphry Slocombe , Lopez Southwestern Kitchen , Relish , The Modern , The Monday Room | Open Open Open Open Closed Closed Open Closed |
| 13 | Chilled Perfection | — | Crystal Grill , Euro Pane , Mama's Fish House , Ola @ The Sanctuary Hotel , Piattini Ristorante , PJ's Family Restaurant , Rice to Riches , Snake River Grill | Closed Relocated Open Unknown Closed Open Open Open |
