| 1 | Grilled | — | Chosun Galbee , Drago's Seafood Restaurant , Lonesome Dove Western Bistro , Mustards Grill , Rathbun's , The Annie Café & Bar , The Rochers at the Ranch House , Tom's Bar-B-Q | Open Open Open Open Closed Renamed Closed Open |
| 2 | Simply Irresistible | — | Beano's Cabin , Cochon Butcher , Craigie on Main , Duarte's Tavern , Flour Bakery & Cafe , Morimoto , The Foundry on Melrose , Vinegar Hill House | Open Open Closed Open Open Closed Closed Open |
| 3 | Regional Favorites | — | Domilise's Restaurant , Magnolias , Mana Musubi , Olneyville NY System , Omni Parker House , Sokolowski's , Tony Luke's , Young's Lobster Pound | Open Open Renamed Open Open Closed Open Open |
| 4 | Sweet Tooth | — | Atlantic Seafood Company , Cipriani , Doughnut Plant , FlipHappy Crepes , Michael's Genuine , Michael's Genuine , Michael's Genuine , Sant Ambroeus , Tartine Bakery , Ted Drewes | Closed Closed Open Closed Open Open Open Open Open Open |
| 5 | Burgers | — | Bobby's Burger Palace , Farm Cafe , Holeman & Finch Public House , J.G. Melon , Louis' Lunch , Pearl's Phat Burgers , The Breslin , The Cherry Cricket | Closed Closed Open Open Open Closed Closed Open |
| 6 | Appetizers | — | Alinea , Bartolotta , BLT Steak , Jacques-Imo's Café , Purple Café and Wine Bar , Sra. Martinez , The Stanton Social | Open Unknown Closed Open Open Closed Closed |
| 7 | In a Bowl | — | Avec , Cafe Fanny , Tasty Hand-Pulled Noodle , Veselka | Open Closed Open Open |
| 8 | Hidden Treasures | — | A&M Halal , Kaaloa's Super J's , Muir Woods Trading Company Cafe , Peter Luger Steak House , Queen Creek Olive Mill , Table 52 , The Hitching Post II | Open Open Open Open Open Closed Open |
| 9 | Sauced | — | Ambassador Dining Room , Colt and Gray , Daddy D'z BBQ Joynt , Don Peppe , FIG , Mayflower Cafe , Scarpetta , Topolobampo | Open Closed Open Open Open Open Open Open |
| 10 | With Fruit | — | Bradley Ogden , Cafe Juanita , Cristina's Restaurant , Frasca , Out The Door , Schmidt's , Versailles | Closed Open Closed Open Closed Closed Open |
| 11 | Sliced | — | Keifers Restaurant , Linn's of Cambria , Motorino , O-Ya Restaurant , Russ & Daughters , The Olde Pink House | Open Open Open Open Open Open |
| 12 | Last Supper | — | Daniel NYC , Ferrara Bakery , French Laundry , Paynes BBQ , Stroud's Restaurant & Bar , Umberto's of New Hyde Park , Vetri Cucina | Open Open Open Open Closed Open Open |
| 13 | Best Thing I Ever Drank | — | Abacus , Barrio Chino , Blue Bottle Coffee Company , Clover Club , The Buena Vista Cafe , The Franklin Fountain Ice Cream , The Franklin Fountain Ice Cream , Velvet Tango Room | Open Open New owners Open Open Open Open Open |
